When Google first came out with their Panda algorithm, Google’s Chief Engineer, Amit Singhal (who designed it) provided a list of potential factors that Google looks at to determine the trustworthiness of any website. This was more than two years ago, but Google has clamped down even harder on its Panda and Penguin algorithms during the past 2 years.
Anything you do with your site that makes it seem spammy to the search engines (such as keyword stuffing) will also make it seem less trustworthy to them. And Google now looks beyond just the obvious. I’ve condensed his trust questions down to 4 main factors:
- Lack of Proofreading
Google’s Trust Factor #1: Expertness
What Google asks: Is this content written by an expert or enthusiast who knows the topic well, or is it shallower in nature? Also, is the site a recognized authority on its topic? In addition, does it contain insightful analysis or interesting information that is beyond obvious?
How your site might be sending a negative signal: You’d be surprised how many websites I see with blogs that have no byline attached to their posts. They’re usually posted by some default “admin” or maybe a first name only, with no bio at the beginning or end of the article, or any sort of link to a bio page.
The fix: Whether or not you write your own blog posts, you need to associate a name with them. If you’re a small company, you’ll often want to use the CEO, owner, or president’s name. It’s also fine to have multiple authors if you’re a larger company. But you will need to establish the credibility of each of them.
Key takeaway: Anyone can write or say anything on the Internet, but that doesn’t make it true. By having a name, face, and bio associated with your content, you’re standing by it and its factualness. Therefore, it makes sense for Google to use this as part of their algorithm.
Google’s Trust Factor #2: Comprehensiveness
What Google asks: Is this the sort of page you’d want to bookmark, share with a friend, or recommend? Does the content provide complete or comprehensive description of the topic? Are the articles short, unsubstantial, or otherwise lacking in helpful specifics?
How your site might be sending a negative signal: It’s not surprising that many blogs I’ve seen that weren’t associating any name with their posts were also not very comprehensive. In fact, they often didn’t appear to be written for real people at all. They seemed to exist only because someone (probably some “SEO expert”) told the site owner they needed a blog for SEO purposes. And of course most of the posts were useless drivel only there to link to other parts of the website via keyworded anchor text. Which of course misses the whole point of having a blog in the first place.
The fix: Remember why blogs exist. The idea of a blog (and content marketing in general) is to add value to your site. It enables you to go above and beyond talking about the products or services you offer. In short, it’s a way to demonstrate your (or your company’s) expertise. Write about what you know and know well. Or, simply don’t do it at all.
Key takeaway: Forget about SEO when you’re trying to decide what to put in your blog and instead think about hot topics in your industry — not so you can rank for those keywords, but so you can provide your own unique perspective. This in turn will be exactly the sort of content Google is looking for — that is, content that people bookmark and share.
Google’s Trust Factor #3: Redundancy for the Sake of Keywords
What Google asks: Does the site have duplicate, overlapping, or redundant articles on the same or similar topics with slightly different keyword variations? Are the topics driven by genuine interests of readers of the site, or does the site generate content by attempting to guess what might rank well in search engines?
How your site might be sending a negative signal: This an old-school SEO technique that worked for so long that some website owners just can’t seem to give it up. I mean, why have one page on any given topic and be relevant for one or two keyword phrases when you can have 10 or more and corner the market on all the relevant phrases? At least that’s how the thinking went. And to a certain extent it did work well in Google before Panda. But when you’ve lost a huge percentage of your organic traffic, you can’t keep clinging to the spammy practices of days gone by.
The fix: Find all the pages of your website that focus on the same or very similar topics and combine them into just one. (If they’re different enough you may be able to keep a few, but be completely honest with yourself here!) It’s especially necessary to remove those pages that are basically just “madlib spam.” After you’ve got them combined, be sure to get your webmaster to 301-redirect all the old URLs to the one new and improved page’s URL.
Key takeaway: The good news is that the newer Google algorithms understand synonyms and the overall meaning of words and phrases.
This means it is no longer necessary to have all the keywords you’d like to be found for on the page itself. Sure, you want to use lots of variations within the page content, but don’t worry if you miss some. If you have a great site that others like to recommend to their audiences, your pages will show up in the search results when relevant.
Google Trust Factor #4: Lack of Proofreading
What Google asks: Does this article have spelling, grammar, stylistic, or factual errors? How much quality control is done on content? Was the article edited well, or does it appear sloppy or hastily produced?
How your site might be sending a negative signal: This trust factor goes beyond merely having typos on your website. While it should be an obvious bad signal, you’d be surprised how many sites I’ve reviewed have content that doesn’t even make sense! It’s as if the people writing the content were only concerned with using keywords, rather than making sense. (OMG!) I’ve also seen content that has been pasted onto sites from elsewhere that didn’t even have proper formatting such as paragraph spacing, or had weird characters that show up in the process.
The fix: Proofread your copy! And treat your website like a precious commodity, because it is!. Pay attention to it, and take care of it in all aspects!
Key takeaway: If even you can’t read your content to make sure that it looks okay and makes some semblance of sense, why would anyone else? And consequently, why would Google want to showcase it?
While Google certainly looks at other trust factors, these 4 are the main troublemakers for most websites. Now it’s time to go review your websites content!